Recovering Detroit's Past for History &
Theater
Charles Bright Article
American History Since 1865
A. Glenn Crothers Syllabus |
Article
Intro to American History
John J. Grabowski Syllabus |
Article
American History
Cecilia Aros Hunter & Leslie Gene Hunter Syllabus | Article
In Search of America's Civil
Rights Movement
Alyssa Picard & Joseph J. Gonzalez Syllabus | Article
Out of Many: Histories of the
U.S.
David A. Reichard Syllabus |
Article
Women & Social Movements
Kathryn Kish Sklar Syllabus |
Article
Law & Society in American
History
John Wertheimer Syllabus |
Article
Colonial & Revolutionary
History of the Southern Tidewater
James P. Whittenburg Syllabus |
Article
American National Character
Michael Zuckerman Syllabus |
Article
Exploring
the Wide World of Sports: Taking a Class to the (Virtual) Olympics
Amy Bass
I teach cultural history at Plattsburgh State University,
a regional public university located on Lake Champlain. The sixty-one
hundred enrolled students are, without question, the faculty's top
priority, so faculty constantly struggle to balance scholarship
and teaching. When I was offered the opportunity to work as a research
consultant for NBC Sports at the Olympics in Sydney, Australia,
in fall 2000, I faced a formidable challenge: How could I, in only
my second year at Plattsburgh, possibly obtain the time to travel
"down under" for seven weeks at the beginning of the academic
calendar? The answer I worked out, with help from my chair, my dean,
and the Honors Program director, embraced the Olympic opportunity
as a classroom experience that would benefit Plattsburgh students.
The end result, a history honors seminar entitled "The Black
Athlete," was a pedagogic innovation that combined distance
and classroom learning by using contemporary and historical materials
to enrich each other. Rather than a logistical nightmare, the course
was an overwhelmingly positive academic experience for those involved
and resulted in an impressive outpouring of original student research
and writing on a variety of historical subjects. While all my courses
deal with historical concepts of time and space, this unique learning
experience required students to move constantly between figures
and events of the past and those in the "real-time" present.
With the Sydney Olympics as our focal point, we concentrated on
historically grounded topics from my own scholarship: nationalism
and internationalism, postwar mass media, alternative methods of
civil rights struggles, and the varied and changing constructions
of race and racism in American culture.
From a Distance: Designing a Course without
a Professor
Since the students were going to be professor-less for the first
weeks of the semester, I developed a plan to keep the course on
track. At a meeting the semester before, I talked to students about
what I wanted to accomplish. I recast my absence as an opportunity
and emphasized how I hoped to bring them to Sydney virtually. I
stressed their responsibility for making the seminar a success.
Lastly, I conveyed the message that this was an experiment, and
that it might not work at all.
That fall, a detailed reading schedule of scholarly historical
articles greeted students. Their central task during the Games was
what I designated the "Olympic Viewing Assignment." For
the duration, students were to create personal, mixed-media journals
based on multiple sources: NBC sports coverage, domestic and foreign
news publications, the Internet, and (because of our close proximity
to Montreal) Canadian print and television coverage. In addition,
each student was to produce a written chronicle of the Olympics
based on a set of common questions regarding media, celebrity, globalization,
amateurism, commerce, spectacle, and, especially, identity. Specific
questions included:
How are different sports represented?
How are identities--nation, race, class, gender, age, ethnicity--performed
in Olympic rituals?
What is the role of the media in creating an athlete's identity?
Which nations seem to dominate the media coverage?
How is the culture of the host country represented?
Electronic Conversations: Using the Internet
as a Classroom
In my absence students interacted with each other via the course
Web page and its online discussion forum; they also corresponded
with me via e-mail. As they shaped the dynamics of the online classroom,
they used it to confer about readings, to set up times to watch
Olympic events together, and to inform each other about relevant
features in media organs. The students, who had yet to spend quality
"face" time together, became a cohesive group, sharing
ideas and insights. Drawing on the news sources available to them,
they became skilled at identifying incidents and topics that corresponded
to the central themes of the course. They discussed, for example,
the Australian jumper Jai Taurima's boast that because of Sydney's
cool temperatures, "You can pretty much knock out all the dark
athletes." They pondered Canadian and American broadcasters'
different styles of commentary and wondered how major league baseball
broadcasts might affect the U.S. TV ratings for Olympic coverage.
They debated amateurism, athlete drug use, and what one student
termed "the business of the Olympics." They marveled at
the Parade of Nations and at how North and South Korea, at least
symbolically, marched as one. They heralded stars such as Marion
Jones, Cathy Freeman, and Ian Thorpe; relished sports rarely seen
on American television (table tennis!); and embraced underdogs such
as Eric Moussambani of Equatorial Guinea, who swam slowly but to
a standing ovation.
Because of the time difference between Sydney and Plattsburgh,
students who watched NBC's coverage carefully noted how the Olympics
were packaged for a prime-time audience, often twenty or so hours
after an event took place. Those who watched Canadian television
(CBC), which aired live footage into the wee hours of the morning,
gave "spoiler alerts" ("DON'T READ THIS IF YOU DON'T
WANT TO KNOW ABOUT. . . . ") to classmates who wanted to watch
it for themselves. One student preferred CBC coverage because, as
a Canadian citizen, he was "incredibly offended and annoyed
by the NBC coverage," especially when commentators used the
word "Canucks" to describe Canadian athletes. "I
apologize if I'm being over-sensitive," the student posted
online, "but the term 'Canuck' isn't exactly something Canadians
relish being called."
I kept my own contributions to the forum to a minimum. Students
became accountable for the quality of the discussion, understanding
that it could be only as good as they made it. They appreciated
that, in one student's words, the forum helped them "keep up
with class reading and work." It became for another an "interesting,
unusual, and fun way to conduct class." As one student recapped
the experience, it "helped us all stay in contact with one
another."
An added benefit of the electronic dialogue was the contact with
celebrity guests who joined us. Throughout my work in Sydney, I
urged colleagues and contacts to enlist in the forum. The lively
discussions ran the gamut of topics. When several gymnasts fell,
for example, because the vault was set at the wrong height, a group
of students expressed concern that it might negatively affect one
young American's overall performance. Michelle Dusserre-Farrell,
who won a silver medal in gymnastics in 1984, responded: "You're
absolutely right. No matter how good of a competitor you are, a
fall like Elise Ray's can mentally make the difference between success
and failure." When another student asked about the impact of
the Olympics on Australia's racial relations, NBC's Bob Costas replied:
I believe the Olympics will have a positive effect on aboriginal
relations here. We've already seen a display of important symbolism
at the Opening Ceremony. Cathy Freeman lighting the torch is similar
in ways to some of the important civil rights moments we have had.
At the same time, the problems are complex, and goodwill alone won't
solve them. It will require much more resolve than that--much more
than just good feelings.1
The negative reactions of the international media to the newest
installment of America's basketball "Dream Team" probably
generated the most heated conversation. Evan Silverman, the director
of Internet Services for the National Basketball Association (NBA),
sparked an animated discussion when he wrote:
Working for the league, I have helped deal with an anti-NBA backlash
for several years, but the disdain for this year's Olympic team
really struck me as out of the ordinary. . . . Putting aside whether
you thought their play was inspired or not, did they really deserve
the derision they received? A few things to think about . . . :
1) Is a team comprised of 12 African-American NBA players too easily
stereotyped by a largely non-African American media? 2) Does the
world resent the Dream Team because they are some of the richest
athletes at the Games? 3) Is the world's anti-U.S. sentiment simply
re-directed to these well-known lightning rods? 4) Do people feel
that the Dream Team does not genuinely care about winning a gold
medal and is simply a product of the NBA marketing machine?2
Going Home: Merging Distance and Classroom
Experiences
When I returned from Sydney, I found a group of students who were
radically disappointed that the Olympics were over. However, we
dived into the classroom portion of the course, beginning with individual
meetings to discuss their Olympic journals, the size and quality
of which were astounding. We began to study a series of common topics:
the history of scientific racism, the Berlin Olympics in 1936, the
Mexico City Olympics in 1968, the legacy of Jackie Robinson, Wilma
Rudolph and the collision of race and gender, the racial politics
of high school football, and Michael Jordan's global corporatism.
As we worked through the readings, students recognized how our subject,
the black athlete, implicated much broader societal issues. As one
student remarked, "The concepts behind the content have many
applications." Another concurred, surprised that she could
"combine my major of biology with the course content of the
black athlete."
For some, the academic journey became personal. Students continually
challenged themselves to use the historical content of the course
to rethink deeply embedded beliefs; one student displayed tears
when admitting that she--like all of us--had fallen victim to accepting
some racial stereotypes. "We dealt with issues that everyone
has strong feelings about," another student remarked in his/her
course evaluation. "We were headed in new directions where
nobody knew what the answers were, so we all went along." Another
student observed, "Social questions that transcended race were
often brought up and showed me things by challenging my own feelings
and conceptions of race, equality, racism, sports and general perceptions
of life." Still another agreed: "The seminar assignments
were key in getting me to ask myself questions of my own ideas and
ingrained attitudes that I probably wouldn't have dealt with otherwise."
Those discoveries translated well into their research endeavors,
which produced highly original and thoughtful papers of substantial
quality. Students, such as one math major, seemed exceptionally
excited about their work: "I feel as though this is the most
important paper I've ever had to write." Many used their Olympic
journals as the basis for more extensive inquiry, attaching the
historical themes they had found in course readings to their observations
about the Sydney Games. Some maintained the contacts they had established
during the Olympics. One student, after watching the documentary
about Muhammad Ali that NBC aired during the Games, interviewed
two NBC writers who had worked on Ali, Joe Gesue and Brian Brown.
The end result was a wonderful paper on documentary images of the
boxing legend entitled "Making Muhammad: The Cinematic Legacy
of the Boxer Who Shook Up the World."
Others, interested in the racial politics of Australia's "stolen
generation," struck up an online relationship with the aboriginal
rights activist Geoff Moore. Because aboriginal culture had played
such a large role in the Opening Ceremony, many opted to write about
the aboriginal runner Cathy Freeman, inarguably the star of the
Sydney Games. One student deconstructed the aboriginal content of
the Opening Ceremony, during which Freeman lit the Olympic flame,
in a paper entitled "The Sydney Games: Aboriginal Representations
and Symbolisms of an Athlete." Another student put together
a complex historiographical overview of the course readings in conjunction
with her Olympic journal to explore the question: "Is Cathy
Freeman a 'Black' Athlete?" Expanding W. E. B. Du Bois's famous
concept of "double consciousness," another probed the
conflicts of race and gender via Freeman, Rudolph, and the African
running legend Tegla Loroupe in a paper entitled "Overcoming
'Triple' Consciousness to Become One Great Runner." Indeed,
after students watched women dominate much of the competition, gender
identity became a popular subject. One student wrote a biography
of the indomitable Marion Jones, while another won the campus Inez
Milholland Boissevain Writing Prize in Women's Studies for her paper,
"Passing the Torch: The Significance of the Torch Relay in
Celebrating Women in the Olympics."
In their research, students continually challenged themselves to
use the historical content of the course in conjunction with the
Olympic spectacle in front of them to rethink expansive historical
concerns. They granted authority to their own observations, connecting
moments in the past with those being created. Students defined their
own "texts," whether by exploring such newspapers as the
Zimbabwe Independent and the Bahrain Tribune or by contacting
people not usually associated with a history class. Thus they redefined
sources of knowledge and expertise to include a range of academic
and nonacademic people, including themselves.
Best of all, they collaborated to make the course succeed, and
its impact continues. One student has used her "Australian
experience" as the basis for her senior thesis project, which
explores Jesse Owens and Cathy Freeman to compare the societal meaning
of segregation with that of assimilation. Another, after completing
papers on representations of black athletes in film and on the assimilation
policies of the "stolen generation," will embark on a
thesis project about the diplomatic politics of the Olympics. Her
inspiration has been her virtual association with Wayne Wilson of
the Amateur Athletic Foundation of Los Angeles, whom she "met"
during the Sydney Games. This same student conveyed the impact the
course had on her when she told me that she still read the Sydney
Morning Herald online almost every day. "I just can't seem
to leave Sydney," she said, perhaps not realizing that she
had never actually left Plattsburgh.
Teaching this course also had a profound impact on me. The relationship
I established with these students was the strongest in my teaching
experience. It broadened my ideas on how students can best capitalize
on the multitude of primary and secondary sources available to them,
forcing me to innovate on the more traditional pedagogical methods
of lectures, note taking, and discussions. It also demonstrated
that Plattsburgh's Honors Program allows for unusual flexibility
and creativity, engendering a student community strong enough to
survive for several weeks without a professor. The next step, then,
is to stretch such opportunities to students in the general curriculum,
perhaps through the learning communities that have been successful
on so many campuses. While doing so would necessitate administrative
support and the shattering of rigid registrar schedules, I hope
in the future to introduce other courses "outside the box"
to a variety of students on a variety of levels, as the rewards
are many.
Amy Bass is an assistant professor of history at Plattsburgh
State University.